Throughout the history of sports, certain teams have maintained dominance, creating a perception that their reign will last indefinitely. However, the 2023 MLB season has proven that even the mightiest can fall. The New York Yankees and St. Louis Cardinals, known for their iconic status and financial prowess, have found themselves at the bottom of their divisions. This reversal of fortune is unprecedented, marking a significant shift in the baseball landscape.
In previous years, the road to victory in the AL East or NL Central often went through the Yankees or Cardinals. These storied franchises had the resources to attract top talent and make deep postseason runs. Last year, both teams finished first in their respective divisions, with standout performances from players like Aaron Judge and the formidable duo of Nolan Arenado and Paul Goldschmidt. Yet, this season has been a completely different story for them.
The Yankees, a perennial powerhouse, are experiencing a rare bout of adversity. They currently find themselves in last place in August, a position they have not occupied since 1992. Similarly, the Cardinals, known for their pitching prowess, are struggling to gain traction and languishing at the bottom of their division for the first time since 1998. This simultaneous descent to the cellar has not been witnessed since 1990, signifying a significant departure from their usual dominance.
While both teams are facing challenging circumstances, their situations differ in some respects. The Cardinals, with a record of 48-61, have slim chances of even contending for a wild-card spot. On the other hand, the Yankees boast a more respectable 56-52 record, suggesting that their struggles may not be as dire. So, what factors have contributed to their current predicament?
The primary reason for their struggles lies in the highly competitive nature of the American League East. Unlike in previous years, every team in the division has a winning record as of August. This rarity is a testament to the strength of the division, with each squad boasting multiple games over .500. The Tampa Bay Rays, currently in second place, would lead any other division except the NL East, where the Atlanta Braves dominate. Even the Toronto Blue Jays, placed third, would be at the top of the standings in the NL or AL Central. Consequently, the Yankees and the Boston Red Sox, two historically strong teams, find themselves playing catch-up within their own division.
Another noteworthy aspect of this shift in power is the Baltimore Orioles’ unexpected emergence at the top of the AL East. This is the first time since 2016 that they have held a share of first place entering August. Despite operating with a payroll significantly smaller than the Yankees’, the Orioles have managed to defy expectations and assert their presence.
The 2023 season has not only disrupted the established order in terms of team standings but has also challenged the correlation between payroll size and on-field success. Traditionally, teams with the highest payrolls tend to dominate the league, ensuring their place in the playoffs. However, this year has seen a departure from that trend.
The New York Mets, Yankees, San Diego Padres, and Philadelphia Phillies possess the four highest payrolls in baseball. Surprisingly, none of these teams currently hold a playoff position, with the Mets and Padres even sporting losing records. This situation is highly unusual, as only once in the wild-card era have the top three payrolls failed to make the playoffs. If these teams continue on their current trajectories, it would mark the first time that the top four payrolls have all been denied a spot in the postseason.
Amidst the chaos and upsets, some teams have risen to prominence after prolonged periods of obscurity. The Cincinnati Reds, for example, find themselves sharing first place in August for only the second time in the past 25 years, the last time being in 2012. Similarly, the Texas Rangers, though not experiencing as long a drought, have not held a share of first place in August since 2016. These teams’ resurgence showcases the unpredictability of the sport and the potential for even the most overlooked teams to make a powerful statement.
Finally, even with the absence of their star player Mike Trout due to injury, the Los Angeles Angels remain in contention for a playoff spot. This is largely due to the incredible performance of Shohei Ohtani, who has emerged as one of the game’s greatest players. The Angels’ proximity to a playoff berth, trailing by only three games, is significant as it marks their closest proximity to the postseason since September 2017.
A Changing Landscape
The 2023 MLB season has ushered in a new era of unpredictability and upheaval. The traditional powerhouses of the Yankees and Cardinals find themselves at the bottom, while unexpected teams like the Orioles and Reds are making their presence known. Payroll size no longer guarantees success, as teams with large budgets struggle to find their footing. The changing landscape of baseball is a testament to the competitiveness and surprises that make the sport so captivating. As fans, we can only embrace and celebrate the ever-changing nature of America’s pastime.
Leave a Reply